Lot # 256: 1953-1970s Massive Baseball Card Collection, Multiples of Mantle, Mays, Aaron & Co. (Approx. 1,200)

Category: Cards: 1950-1959

Starting Bid: $200.00

Bids: 14 (Bid History)

Time Left: Auction closed


I have one to sell!

Lot / Auction Closed




This lot is closed. Bidding is not allowed.

Item was in Auction "April 2, 2026: Spring Auction",
which ran from 3/16/2026 2:00 AM to
4/2/2026 10:30 PM



Similar to an adjacent lot of football cards, this is your classic childhood baseball card collection, with the greatest emphasis on the 1970s and beyond, with almost all carefully installed in nine-pocket sheets in (largely) team-oriented fashion. While Topps and Bowman cards dominate, there are also samplings from food and regional issues like Post Cereal, Kellogg’s, Hostess and Johnston Cookies, the famed inserts and peripheral issues, like Topps Coins, Stamps and Supers. As in most such collections, the cards reveal what we used to call honest wear; another hallmark of such collections is at least modest improvement in condition over time. While 1950s keys can be largely Fair to Poor and perhaps a bit better in the 1960s closer to Fair to Good, ultimately more like Good to Very Good or above by the 1970s. That said, the roster of headliners is stunning, with literally dozens of cards from the Tier One Hall of Famers, including the likes Mickey Mantle, Henry Aaron, Willie Mays, Ted Williams and Sandy Koufax, to name a few. With Hall of Famers lurking on virtually every page, the massive grouping presents a real opportunity for a savvy bidder willing to poke through the pile for treasures. In short, this is the kind of lot that would have fit right in at the legendary Saturday night auctions at the iconic Willow Grove shows outside Philadelphia in the 1980s. As noted, almost all the cards remain in their original binders; the arrangement broadly by teams makes the typical chronological listing problematic, but we'll do our best to provide an efficient look at the curriculum. In the listing below, the card indicated is the player’s regular-issue version unless otherwise indicated. Here’s a broad breakdown: 1) Hall of Famers Grouping (150), all Topps unless otherwise indicated – Mickey Mantle (4), including a 1955 Bowman (Poor), 1961 Topps (Fair), 1961 Topps MVP (Excellent-Plus) and 1962 Life Magazine Post Cereal Insert (Good); Henry Aaron (9), including Topps from 1959 (Poor), 1961, 1963, 1970, 1970 All-Star, 1973, 1974 and two 1974 Specials; Sandy Koufax (2) – 1959 Topps (Poor) and 1961 Topps (Ex-Mt-Plus), Willie Mays (4), including 1959 Topps (Fair), 1963, 1969 Deckle Edge, 1972 In Action and 1972 Kellogg’s; Clemente (4) – including 1961 Topps (Ex-Mt-Plus), 1972, 1972 In Action and 1973; Ernie Banks (4) – including 1961 Topps All-Star, 1963, 1963 Post Cereal and 1971 Kellogg’s; Frank Robinson (6) – including 1959 Topps, 1961, 1961 All-Star, 1963 (2) and 1974; Ted Williams (19) – with 18 Fleer Life of Ted Williams from 1959 and a 1960 Fleer All-Time Greats; Yogi Berra (5), including 1961 Topps, 1953 (2), 1964 and 1974; Brooks Robinson (3) – including 1961 Topps, 1963 Post Cereal and 1974; Pete Rose (6) – including 1970 Topps, 1973, 1974 and 1976; Al Kaline (5) – including 1961 Topps, 1961 Post Cereal, 1962 (2, Near-Mint) and 1963; and Babe Ruth (16) – all 1962 Topps Life of Babe Ruth Subset, Ex-Mt to Nr-Mt; plus additional Hall of Famers with multiple examples (mostly 1970s Topps), including Yastrzemski, Brett, Ryan, Allen, Carew, Santo, Gibson, Simmons, Brock, Bench, Morgan, Dawson, Marichal, Torre, Yount, Mathews (1953 Topps – Fair, 1954 Bowman – Fair and 1957 Topps), Dick Williams, McCovey, Mazeroski, Drysdale, Perez, Stargell, Seaver and Palmer; 2) 1950s Topps and Bowman (approx. 125) mostly Fair to Poor, including 1953 Topps cards of Campanella and Mize; 1954 Topps of Lasorda Rookie and Irvin; 1954 Johnston Cookies (20) – mostly Fair to Good, including Spahn, Bruton and Logan; 1955 Bowman Reese (Good o/c); 1957 Topps (22) – mostly Good to Excellent, including Colavito Rookie, Score, Erskine, Slaughter and those stuffy League Presidents; and 1959 Topps (56) – mostly Good to Excellent with some below, including Snider (2 – Excellent and VG-Ex), Richardson, Howard and Allison Rookie; 3) Large Album with primarily 1970s Topps (525) – some 1960s Topps, heaviest 1974 Topps and very light between 1965-72, includes some food and regional issues; and 4) Miscellaneous (400) – includes 1964 Topps Coins (both versions of No. 131 Mantle All-Star, No. 150 Clemente All-Star and No. 159 Koufax All-Star, 1961 and 1962 Topps Stamps (44), with 1961 Stamps of Maris, Aparicio, Frank Robinson, Kaline and Wilhelm and 1962 Stamps of Mays, Banks and Minoso; 1971 Topps Supers (3) – of Jenkins, Gaston and Stargell. Whew! That’s a lot of stuff. Don't sue me if I miscounted here or there.

Views: 755